As more companies cover abortion travel in health insurance plans, are interstate travel bans next?
- More companies are covering travel costs for out-of-state abortions after the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade
- But some states like Texas are trying to prohibit travel across state lines for an abortion
- Experts say travel benefits to get an abortion inevitably will face legal challenges
Even before the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, 11 states limited whether employer-based insurance plans could cover abortions with exceptions for rape, incest, life endangerment and fetal impairment.
But those states, which include Texas, Indiana and Oklahoma, couldn’t prevent plans from covering out-of-state abortions, said Harvey Cotton, a principal lawyer within Ropes & Gray’s benefits consulting group.
Since the Court's ruling paved the way for some states to pass abortion bans, a slew of companies including Google, Kroger and Disney offered employees out-of-state coverage and reimbursement for travel expenses.
But it’s too early to tell whether those benefits will make it through inevitable legal challenges.
Does private health insurance cover abortions?
Before Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, which resulted in Roe being overturned, “employers who wanted to offer a broad scope of reproductive health benefits could do so,” Cotton said, except for plans that were fully insured.
These plans are subject to state regulations because the insurers, not employers, assume the financial risk of providing health care coverage. People who are enrolled in a fully insured plan may not be able to receive out-of-state coverage for abortions.
Most employer-based plans are self-funded, according to a 2021 study published by the Kaiser Family Foundation, meaning employers assume the financial risk of insuring employees and the insurance plans. These plans are subject to federal laws such as Employee Retirement Income Security Act that supersede state laws that regulate insurance.
Although there isn’t sufficient data, Michelle Banker, director of reproductive rights and health litigation at the National Women’s Law Center, said that before the Dobbs ruling it was less likely that low-wage workers received any abortion coverage “just by virtue of the fact that more higher-paid jobs offer health benefits.”
Can telemedicine step in?:Demand for telemedicine abortions increases but could face legal challenges post-Roe
To find out how or if an employment-based health insurance plan covers abortions, employees should ask for a copy of their plan’s document and search for terms like “reproductive care,” Banker recommends.
You do not have to specify interest in information on abortion coverage, she said.
Or, contact an abortion provider and ask if the provider can process your insurance or contact your insurance provider and ask about out-of-pocket expenses.
Will there be interstate abortion travel bans?
Cotton said he expects a “variation in state’s interest in regulating travel.” The uncertainty has some clients holding off on reimbursing employees’ abortion-related travel expenses, he said.
Some states that ban or restrict abortion will have “no interest in restricting travel,” Cotton added, but states like Texas are “signaling a very aggressive approach to employers that are going to attempt to do this.”
State abortion bans, the new normal? One woman’s 17-hour journey to get an abortion.
In his concurring opinion of the court's ruling to overturn Roe v. Wade, Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote that states should not be allowed to bar people from traveling to get an abortion “based on the constitutional right to interstate travel.”
If there is a ruling on whether employers can cover travel costs for someone to receive an abortion, “it's going to affect presumably more than just abortions,” Cotton told USA TODAY, because many companies cover travel costs for a variety of medical procedures, including cancer treatment and organ transplants.
Cost of getting an abortion hits low-income people hardest, Justices say
Former Justice Stephen Breyer and Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan wrote in their dissenting opinion that traveling to get an out-of-state abortion is less of a legal question than an affordability question.
“In states that bar abortion, women of means will still be able to travel to obtain the services they need. It is women who cannot afford to do so who will suffer most.”
For instance, in Texas, where abortions are banned after fetal cardiac activity is detectable – around six weeks after conception – a person would have to travel 494 miles round trip, or seven hours by car, on average to get an abortion, according to research published last year by the Guttmacher Institute, a pro-abortion-rights research organization.
Where is abortion legal in the world? Canada, other countries allow abortions and these ban them.
Abortion illegal in Texas again:Texas Supreme Court blocks order that allowed abortions to resume
That could require someone to miss a full day’s earnings. In addition, with gas prices hovering around $4.40 a gallon in Texas, it would cost about $90 to complete the trip for a car that gets 24.2 miles per gallon, the average mileage for cars driven in the U.S.
More state abortion bans are "only going to exacerbate" the financial burdens of getting an abortion, and they will disproportionately affect people of color, Banker said.
But "there are strong (legal) arguments in support of the ability of employers to offer benefits and take steps to protect their employees" that could help alleviate the burden for some Americans.
Elisabeth Buchwald is a personal finance and markets correspondent for USA TODAY. You can follow her on Twitter @BuchElisabeth and sign up for our Daily Money newsletter here